Muddled Spratley

A muddler-headed version of Dick Prankard's 1949 Doc Spratley, tied by Hans Weilenmann with a black body, gold rib, grizzly tail, pheasant tail underwing and clipped deer hair head. It imitates chironomid and caddis pupae, retrieved slowly in lakes.

Muddled Spratley fly pattern - imitates Chironomid Pupae, Caddis Pupae tied for Trout
  • Advanced
  • Spring, Summer, Fall
  • Trout
  • Size 10

Watch it tied

One video

A muddler-headed version of Dick Prankard's 1949 Doc Spratley, tied by Hans Weilenmann with a black body, gold rib, grizzly tail, pheasant tail underwing and clipped deer hair head. It imitates chironomid and caddis pupae, retrieved slowly in lakes.

More Nymphs

See all

Materials

Hook
Partridge BIN #10
Thread
Uni-thread 8/0, black
Rib
Polar flash, gold
Tail
Grizzly barbs
Body
Yorkshire flybody fur, black (or any semi-coarse black dubbing)
Underwing
Cock pheasant center tail barbs - sparse
Flash
UV Ice Dub, tan - very sparse
Wing
Deer hair - sparse
Head
Deer hair, spun and clipped - sparse

Overview

The body is Yorkshire flybody fur, or any semi-coarse black dubbing, ribbed with fine gold polar flash over a grizzly barb tail. A sparse underwing of cock pheasant center tail barbs sits beneath a very sparse touch of tan UV Ice Dub flash and a thin deer hair wing, and the head is deer hair spun in and clipped tight rather than wound as conventional hackle. The clipped head gives it a muddler profile that pushes water on the retrieve, while the dark body and flash read from below like a chironomid or caddis pupa. The Doc Spratley it is based on was created in 1949 by Dick Prankard of Mount Vernon, Washington, and is one of the best-known lake flies of the Pacific Northwest. Fish it on a sinking or intermediate line with a slow hand-twist or short strips over shoals and drop-offs.

Related patterns

Behavior & presentation

Natural Behavior
Chironomid pupae rise slowly from the lake bottom to hatch, and caddis pupae swim up fast through the same water. Both are most exposed in the last few feet below the surface.
Where Trout Eat It
Trout cruise shoals and weed edges in 3-15 feet of water, picking off pupae as they ascend, especially in the morning and evening.
How to Fish It
Let the fly sink close to the bottom on a sinking or intermediate line, then bring it back with a slow hand-twist or short strips and pauses so it rises and falls like an ascending pupa. Speed up the retrieve when caddis are hatching.
Best Water
Shoal edges, the lip of a drop-off, weed beds, and lake margins where the bottom shelves from shallow to deep.
Strike Type
A steady pull or sudden weight on the line during the retrieve; keep the rod tip low and set with a strip rather than a lift.

Fishing strategy

Rigging Suggestions
Use an intermediate or type 3 sinking line with a 9-12 foot leader to 3X-4X fluorocarbon. Count the fly down to just above the weeds before starting the retrieve.
Seasonal Timing
Spring through fall on lakes; best from late May into July during chironomid hatches, and on summer evenings when sedges are moving.
Pro Tips
Vary the body color (black, olive, green, red) to match the pupae that are hatching. If trout follow without taking, slow down and add longer pauses.

Entomology

Midge larvae live in the bottom mud of lakes and seal themselves into pupal cases before swimming to the top, often hanging under the film for minutes. Sedges hatch in a rush instead, and that steady supply of slow and fast prey keeps lake trout feeding on the shoals.

Order
Diptera
Family
Chironomidae
Common name
Chironomid
Organism
insect
Life stage
pupa

Pattern details

  • Stillwater
  • British Columbia
  • strip-retrieve
  • active-retrieve
  • searching-pattern
  • classic