Comparadun

The Comparadun is a versatile dry fly pattern that effectively imitates a variety of mayfly species. Its unique, splayed deer hair wing provides excellent visibility and helps the fly ride flush on the water's surface.

Comparadun fly pattern - imitates Mayflies tied for Trout
Essential pattern
  • Intermediate
  • Spring, Summer
  • Trout
  • Size 10–20

Watch it tied

Pick a tyer
Harrop Hairwing DunNext flyBarr's Vis-A-DunNext flyH&L VariantNext flyBDE MayflyNext fly

The Comparadun is a versatile dry fly pattern that effectively imitates a variety of mayfly species. Its unique, splayed deer hair wing provides excellent visibility and helps the fly ride flush on the water's surface.

More Dry Flies

See all

Materials

Hook
Tiemco 100 SP-BL, size #10–#20
Thread
50 Denier GSP
Tails
Tailing Fibers
Abdomen
Callibaetis Super Fine Dubbing
Wing
Nature's Spirit Deer Hock Or Comparadun Deer
Thorax
Callibaetis Super Fine Dubbing

Overview

Tied without hackle, the Comparadun uses fine dubbing for the body and a fan-shaped deer hair wing tied upright and splayed. Its low-profile design makes it ideal for imitating mayflies in slow, clear water.

Related patterns

Behavior & presentation

Natural Behavior
Newly emerged duns float trapped in surface film, wings held upright while exoskeletons harden. This extended drift during the drying phase creates predictable feeding lanes where trout methodically sip vulnerable adults.
Where Trout Eat It
In streams, focus on glides, pools, and soft tail-outs where mayflies collect. In lakes, work weed edges and drop-offs during calm conditions.
How to Fish It
Dead drift with slack line casts to avoid drag. Position downstream of rising fish for delicate upstream presentations.
Best Water
Target glides, pools, tail-outs, and drop-offs where emergers concentrate in slow, smooth currents.
Strike Type
Look for subtle sips, quiet rises, or expanding surface rings as trout take floating duns.

Fishing strategy

Rigging Suggestions
Use a 9-12 foot leader tapered to 5X or 6X tippet for selective trout in clear water. A delicate presentation is critical. The fly should be fished alone to avoid tangles with its low-profile design.
Seasonal Timing
Prime during mayfly hatches from April through August. Most effective when water temperatures range from 50-65°F, triggering consistent mayfly emergences throughout the day.
Pro Tips
The deer hair wing keeps the fly riding flush in the surface film, matching the profile of natural mayfly duns. Change fly size and body color to match the specific mayfly species emerging. The no-hackle design is less visible to spooky fish.
From River & Run

Where to fish it

Rivers anglers pair with this fly, with local shops that stock it.

Open River & Run

River details and fly shops from River & Run, our sister site.

Entomology

Mayfly duns ride the current with upright wings held vertical, trapped in the surface film while their exoskeletons harden during the critical post-emergence drying phase. Trout rise confidently to this vulnerable life stage because the insects cannot escape for several minutes after hatching, allowing fish to feed methodically on predictable drift lines where emergers concentrate in smooth tailouts and glides.

Order
Ephemeroptera
Common name
Mayfly
Organism
insect
Life stage
adult

Pattern details

  • Stillwater
  • Moving Water
  • Rocky Mountain
  • Northeast
  • Great Lakes
  • Midwest
  • dead-drift
  • baetis-hatch
  • comparadun-family
  • searching-pattern
  • low-clear-water

Get this fly

Comparadun, tied and ready to fish

Hook #10 to #20 · Intermediate