CDC Comparadun

The CDC Comparadun is a versatile dry fly that is highly effective during a mayfly hatch. It's tied with CDC feathers to provide a realistic, delicate silhouette on the water, making it irresistible to trout.

CDC Comparadun fly pattern - imitates Mayflies tied for Trout
  • Intermediate
  • Spring, Summer
  • Trout
  • Size 12–16

Watch it tied

Pick a tyer
Purple HazeNext flySLS Improved Sparkle DunNext flyH&L VariantNext flyBarr's Vis-A-DunNext fly

The CDC Comparadun is a versatile dry fly that is highly effective during a mayfly hatch. It's tied with CDC feathers to provide a realistic, delicate silhouette on the water, making it irresistible to trout.

More Dry Flies

See all

Materials

Hook
Tiemco 100, size #12–#16
Thread
Olive Dun 8/0 Uni-Thread
Body
Superfine dubbing in olive
Wing
Natural dun CDC feathers
Tail
Coq de Leon fibers

Overview

A low-profile dry fly using CDC fibers instead of deer hair for the comparadun-style wing. Combined with a slender dubbed body and split tail (usually microfibets), it sits flush in the film and imitates mayfly duns with delicate realism. Perfect for slow, clear water where soft presentation is critical.

Related patterns

Behavior & presentation

Natural Behavior
The freshly emerged dun floats with wings upright, trapped in the surface film as its exoskeleton hardens. Unable to fly immediately, it drifts helplessly in feeding lanes, a perfect target for selective risers.
Where Trout Eat It
Fish rise rhythmically in slicks, glides, and tail-outs where surface currents concentrate emerging mayflies in predictable lanes.
How to Fish It
Drag-free drifts are critical—the CDC wing sits flush in the film, mimicking the natural's vulnerable float. Upstream presentations reduce drag.
Best Water
Focus on glides with smooth surface, riffles where mayflies struggle to emerge, and flats in lakes during hatch windows.
Strike Type
Visible rises with subtle sips or confident splashy takes, depending on fish size and hatch density.

Fishing strategy

Rigging Suggestions
Use 6X tippet on a 10-12 foot tapered leader for drag-free presentations. The no-hackle design requires careful leader management to avoid drag on selective fish.
Seasonal Timing
Most productive during (April-June) and (July-August) when mayfly hatches are concentrated. Water temperatures of 52-68°F trigger consistent emergences of Baetis, PMD, and Callibaetis species.
Pro Tips
The CDC wing provides natural buoyancy and a realistic mayfly silhouette. Apply floatant to the wing before fishing. Size and color match your local mayfly species—typically size 14-20 in olive, tan, or gray.

Entomology

Adult mayflies rest on the water surface with wings upright after emergence, floating downstream in slower currents while their exoskeleton hardens before taking flight. Trout feed confidently on these freshly emerged duns because they're trapped in the surface film and unable to escape quickly, presenting consistent drag-free drift patterns. The concentration of hatching mayflies during emergence windows creates predictable feeding lanes where fish rise rhythmically to sip adults.

Order
Ephemeroptera
Common name
Mayfly
Organism
insect
Life stage
adult

Pattern details

  • Stillwater
  • Moving Water
  • Rocky Mountain
  • Northeast
  • Great Lakes
  • Midwest
  • dead-drift
  • baetis-hatch
  • comparadun-family
  • searching-pattern
  • low-clear-water

Get this fly

CDC Comparadun, tied and ready to fish

Hook #12 to #16 · Intermediate