Killer Mayfly

The Killer Mayfly imitates an emerging mayfly, built on a Tiemco 200R with dun tail fibers, a slim black midge tubing body, and an olive Superfine dubbing thorax capped with a clear Scud Back or Medallion Sheeting casing that mimics a wing pad splitting open. Soft partridge fibers form struggling legs, giving selective trout a low-riding target during Blue-Winged Olive and other mayfly hatches on Western rivers.

Killer Mayfly fly pattern - imitates Mayflies tied for Trout
  • Intermediate
  • Spring, Summer
  • Trout
  • Size 16–22

Watch it tied

Pick a tyer
CDC Biot DunNext flyKlipspringer Cripple MayflyNext flyFloating NymphNext flyLast Chance CrippleNext fly

The Killer Mayfly imitates an emerging mayfly, built on a Tiemco 200R with dun tail fibers, a slim black midge tubing body, and an olive Superfine dubbing thorax capped with a clear Scud Back or Medallion Sheeting casing that mimics a wing pad splitting open. Soft partridge fibers form struggling legs, giving selective trout a low-riding target during Blue-Winged Olive and other mayfly hatches on Western rivers.

More Dry Flies

See all

Materials

Hook
Tiemco 200R, sizes #16-#22
Thread
Black UTC 70
Tail
Dun Mayfly Tails
Body
Black Midge Tubing
Thorax
Olive Superfine Dubbing
Casing
Scud Back or Clear Medallion Sheeting
Legs
Partridge

Overview

Tied in sizes #16-22, the slim black midge tubing body creates a segmented, translucent abdomen while the olive Superfine dubbing thorax is capped with clear Scud Back or Medallion Sheeting pulled over the top, mimicking the sheen of a nymphal shuck splitting to release the winged adult. Dun mayfly tail fibers trail behind, and sparse partridge fibers swept back suggest legs kicking free of the shuck. Fished in the film on light tippet, it covers the vulnerable transitional stage trout target hardest during spring and summer mayfly emergences.

Related patterns

Behavior & presentation

Natural Behavior
Mayfly duns ride the current after emerging, holding their wings upright as they dry. Fish target these vulnerable adults during the drift.
Where Trout Eat It
Most productive in slow-moving pools, eddies, and spring creek flats where mayfly duns gather after emerging. Trout in slack water have time to inspect the realistic extended-body silhouette.
How to Fish It
Cast upstream with drag-free drift across feeding lanes, using reach casts to extend natural float. In slower water, allow occasional rise-and-fall motion to imitate duns struggling on surface.
Best Water
Target slow pools with smooth surfaces, eddy lines where duns accumulate, and spring creek flats 1-3 feet deep.
Strike Type
Fish rise deliberately with quiet sips or confident head rises; delay your set slightly to let the fish close its mouth.

Fishing strategy

Rigging Suggestions
Use 9-12 foot leaders with 5X or 6X tippet for rivers, 4X for lakes. Can fish solo or with small nymph dropper 18-24 inches below.
Seasonal Timing
Most effective May through September during mayfly hatches, particularly productive during June and July when multiple species emerge. Water temperatures between 55-65°F are ideal.
Pro Tips
CDC wings and quality hackle provide floatation in various water types. When fishing lake, use slow hand-twist retrieve to add subtle movement. The high-floating design makes this pattern visible in low light conditions.

Entomology

Adult mayflies hover just above the water surface before gracefully settling to deposit eggs, their translucent wings catching sunlight as they bounce along with the current. Trout have evolved to recognize the silhouette and behavior of these delicate insects, timing their rises precisely to intercept them during peak hatch periods when concentrated feeding opportunities emerge.

Order
Ephemeroptera
Common name
Mayfly
Organism
insect
Life stage
adult

Pattern details

  • Stillwater
  • Moving Water
  • Rocky Mountain
  • dead-drift
  • baetis-hatch
  • low-clear-water

Get this fly

Killer Mayfly, tied and ready to fish

Hook #16 to #22 · Intermediate