
Keys to Mayflies
| Swimmer |
Crawler |
Clinger |
Burrower |
Mayflies are synonymous with flyfishing. Since the history of the sport, the two have been closely linked. The reasons why are obvious; no other insect is more available to the trout, and more noticeable to us humans, than the mayfly. Mayflies live almost their whole life under water. They are available to the fish as nymphs year round. When they finally emerge, they resemble small sailboats being blown around by their upright wings, lazily going where the wind and the current take them. This, the time of the hatch, is when the mayflies are the most vulnerable, and is the time that is treasured by flyfishermen the world over. Once they have left the water, the mayflies most go through one more change that will make them capable of reproduction. The insects then return to the water to breed and die, once again becoming food for the trout.
The stages of life for a mayfly are egg, nymph, dun and spinner. Eggs can be deposited by the spinners in several ways; one is ovipositing, where eggs are dropped into the stream from above. Another form of egg laying takes place when the mature adult crawls onto aquatic vegetation (or your waders) and attaches their eggs to the plant. When the nymphs or larvae hatch, they crawl around the stream or lake bottom; it is usually a year before they are ready to hatch. Hatching (the metamorphosis from the juvenile stage to the first flying stage) can also come about in different ways. The first is for the nymph to swim or float to the stream's surface, where it will break open its nymphal shuck; a fully formed dun, or subimago, will crawl on to the water's surface, dry its wings, and fly away. The second form of emergence is for the dun to crawl from the nymphal shuck onto the stream bottom, then swim to the surface as an adult fly. A few days after the duns (subimagos) have hatched, they shed once again, their body color changes, and their wings become clear; most importantly they become mature adults capable of reproduction. This reproductive stage is called the spinner or imago. The spinners will mate in huge swarms over the top of the water. Once they have mated, they fall dead onto the water's surface, spent winged, like hundreds of little crosses. Due to the sheer number of flies, a spinner fall can be one of the most productive, but often frustrating, times to fish.
Identifying Mayflies
A nymph can be identified as a mayfly if it has all of the following characteristics:
1) Gills along its abdomen
2) A single claw at the end of its legs.
3) One set of visible wing pads.
4) 2 or 3 tails
Mayfly adults have the following characteristics:
1) 2 sets of wings that are upright at rest.
2) 2 or 3 tails.
3) A long, usually slender, body.
Types Of Mayflies
There are approximately 570 North American species of mayflies. Since it would be very difficult to identify them all on this web page we will break them down into groups based on the behavioral characteristics of the nymphs. The four basic groups are Swimmers, Clingers, Crawlers and Burrowers. The following keys should give you a good start on identifying and understanding the basic types of mayfly nymphs and adults.
Swimmers
Mayfly Swimmer Nymph
|
Mayfly Swimmer Wing
|
ILLUSTRATIONS BY: ANDY COOPER
Identifying Characteristics of Swimmers:
- Nymphs
- Round and streamlined body.
- Tails are fringed with fine hair.
- Oval gills are positioned on the side of the abdomen.
- Adults
- Small body size.
- Base of veins MP2 and CuA do not diverge from the base of MP1.
- Two or three tails are present.
-
Table of Major Swimmer Hatches
Families
|
Genera
|
Species
|
Common name
|
Baetidae
|
Baetis
|
|
Blue-Winged Olive
|
|
|
Callibaetis
|
|
Speckle-Wing Quill
|
|
|
Pseudocleon
|
|
Tiny Blue-Wing Olive
|
Siphlonuridae
|
Siphlonurus
|
|
Black or Gray Drake
|
|
|
Ameletus
|
|
Dark Brown Spinner
|
|
|
Isonychia
|
|
White-Gloved Howdy
|
Fly patterns for Swimmers.
|
Nymph
|
Emerger
|
Dun
|
Spinner
|
Crawler
Mayfly Crawler Nymph
|
Mayfly Crawler Nymph
|
Mayfly Crawler Wing
|
ILLUSTRATIONS BY: ANDY COOPER
Identifying Characteristics of Crawler :
- Nymphs
- Plate like gills on top of abdomen.
- Forked gills with no fringes.
- Adults
- Series of short intercalary veins present along the outer margins of the fore wing and not attached to other veins.
-
Table of Major Crawler Hatches
Families
|
Genera
|
Species
|
Common name
|
Ephemerellidae
|
Attenella
|
attenuata
|
Tiny Dun Variant
|
|
Drunella
|
cornuta
grandis
flavilinea
coloradenis
|
Large Blue Wing Olive
Western Green Drake
Small Western Green Drake
Slate-Winged Olive
|
|
|
Ephemerella
|
subvaria
rotunda
dorothea
inermis
E. infrequens
|
Dark Hendrickson
Light Hendrickson
Sulfurs
Pale Morning Dun
|
|
|
Serratella
|
deficiens
tibialis
|
Little Dark Hendrickson
Small Western Hendrickson
|
Tricorythodidae
|
Tricorythodes
|
|
Tricos
|
Caenidae
|
Caenis
|
hilaris
|
Tiny White Winged Curse
|
Leptophlebiidae
|
Leptophlebia
|
cupida
|
Red Quill
|
|
|
Paraleptophlebia
|
adoptiva
|
Blue Quill
|
Fly patterns for Crawlers.
|
Nymph
|
Emerger
|
Dun
|
Spinner
|
Clinger
Mayfly Clinger Nymph
|
Mayfly Clinger Wing
|
ILLUSTRATIONS BY: ANDY COOPER
Identifying Characteristics of Clinger :
- Nymphs
- Head is larger and wider than abdomen excluding gills.
- Body is very flat.
- Plate like gills on the side of the abdomen.
- Adults
- Two sets of cubital intercalories.
-
Table of Major Clinger Hatches
Families
|
Genera
|
Species
|
Common name
|
Heptageniidae
|
Epeorus
|
pleuralis
|
Quill Gordon
|
|
Leucrocuta
|
|
Little Evening Sulphur
|
|
Rhithrogena
|
morrisoni
|
Western March Brown
|
|
Stenonema
|
vicarium
|
American March Brown
|
Fly patterns for Clingers.
|
Nymph
|
Emerger
|
Dun
|
Spinner
|
Burrower
Mayfly Burrower Nymph
|
Mayfly Burrower Wing
|
ILLUSTRATIONS BY: ANDY COOPER
Identitifying Characteristics of Burrower :
- Nymphs
- Forked gills along the abdomen which are fringed ( covered with small hairs).
- Large mandibles (mouth parts) that form tusks.
- Adults
- Veins MP1, MP2 and CuA strongly diverge from the base of the fore wing.
- Very large mayfly with large wings.
Table of Major Burrower Hatches
Families
|
Genera
|
Species
|
Common name
|
Ephemeridae
|
Ephemera
|
guttulata
simulans
|
Eastern Green Drake
Brown Drake
|
|
|
Hexagenia
|
limbata
|
Big Yellow May
|
Polymitarcyidae
|
Ephoron
|
|
White Fly
|
Fly patterns for Burrowers.
|
Nymph
|
Emerger
|
Dun
|
Spinner
|
| Metamorphosis |
Life Stages of Insects |
Keys to Larvae |
Keys to Pupae |
Keys to Nymphs |
|
Keys to Adults |
Keys to Stoneflies |
Keys to Caddisflies |
Keys to Midges |
Return to Entomology Page